Pantera released four albums before Cowboys from Hell, and have since declared this fifth one their official debut. It was their first for a major label, and the record where they dropped glam for the heavier, grooving sound that made them. Along the way the producer they wanted quit two days before sessions began for a bigger cheque, and the label man who signed them went to see the band play because Hurricane Hugo had stranded him in Texas.

Released on 24 July 1990 on Atco (and often styled Cowboys From Hell), it sold slowly, did not chart until 1992, and was finally certified 2x Platinum in the United States in 2023. It is now regarded as one of the first groove metal albums.

Album Facts

FieldDetail
ArtistPantera
AlbumCowboys from Hell
Release Date24 July 1990
LabelAtco Records
Producer(s)Terry Date, with Pantera as co-producers
Studio(s)Pantego Sound, Pantego, Texas
Genre / SubgenreGroove metal, thrash metal
Track Count12
Total Runtime57:39
Billboard 200 Peak117 (2010 reissue)
Other Notable Chart PeaksUS Heatseekers 27 (1992); Sweden 46 (1995); UK Rock & Metal Albums 32 (2010)
CertificationsUS 2x Platinum; UK, Argentina, Australia, Japan Gold
US Certified Units2,000,000 (2x Platinum)
Key Singles"Cowboys from Hell", "Psycho Holiday"; "Cemetery Gates" (promo)

Cultural Context

Metal's commercial momentum was fading in the late 1980s as grunge drew the media's attention, according to Metal Hammer's retelling. Anselmo found the genre's image cheesy and pointed to MTV's Headbangers Ball as an example. Three other records landed in the months after Cowboys from Hell:

  • Facelift by Alice in Chains, 21 August 1990.
  • Rust in Peace by Megadeth, 24 September 1990.
  • Seasons in the Abyss by Slayer, 9 October 1990.

The Band's Story Up to This Point

Pantera formed in Arlington, Texas, in 1981 around the Abbott brothers, drummer Vinnie Paul and guitarist Darrell, and started out as a covers band playing Van Halen, Judas Priest and Def Leppard. Three glam-leaning albums with singer Terry Glaze followed (Metal Magic, Projects in the Jungle, I Am the Night), then Phil Anselmo arrived in 1986 and Power Metal appeared in 1988, a mix of glam, traditional metal and thrash.

Shortly after Power Metal, Megadeth needed a guitarist and asked Darrell to join. He insisted Vinnie Paul come too, Megadeth had already hired Nick Menza, and Darrell stayed put. Anselmo has described the mood he brought into the band in blunt terms.

"I'd had it with the formula of what metal was supposed to sound like, and what a heavy metal dude was supposed to be."

Phil Anselmo, Metal Hammer, 2010

Pre-production & Demos

Writing ran through 1988 and 1989. Anselmo says he played Slayer's "At Dawn They Sleep" for Darrell in Texas in early 1988, and Loudwire reports the band spent about six months writing, leaning on thrash with a Southern groove on top, a feel later dubbed "power groove". Loudwire names "The Art of Shredding" as the first song written, and "Psycho Holiday" and "Heresy" came out of one two-day jam. "We were on fire," Vinnie Paul said.

The band cut a self-produced demo in 1989 with eleven tracks. Ten reached the album, while "The Will to Survive" was dropped early. "Primal Concrete Sledge" and "Clash with Reality" were the last songs written.

Getting a deal was harder. Epic and Roadracer showed interest but steered the band towards producers with a "more commercial type" of approach, Vinnie Paul said. Pantera were turned down "28 times by every major label on the face of the Earth", and Paul remembered the effect.

"We'd been turned down by every record company in the States, so we were angry and that all came out in the music!"

Vinnie Paul, quoted in Metal Hammer

Atco's Mark Ross, sent to see them by label boss Derek Shulman after Hurricane Hugo left him stranded in Texas, rang Shulman that night to recommend signing them. Vinnie Paul says the show was a birthday party at a Mexican restaurant in Fort Worth. Ross later recalled the first song.

"By the end of the first song, my jaw was on the floor."

Mark Ross, quoted by Blabbermouth, 2010

Atco agreed, then the band waited about six months before recording began.

Creating Cowboys from Hell

The sessions took place at Pantego Sound, a studio owned by the Abbotts' father, Jerry, who had worked there as an engineer. Dates are disputed: Rex Brown told Metal Hammer in 2010 that it ran from February to April 1990, while Anselmo has said it was recorded in 1989. Wikipedia's summary is late 1989 to April 1990.

Max Norman, known for his Ozzy Osbourne work, was the first choice as producer. Loudwire reports the band's producer budget was $30,000, and that Norman was offered $50,000 to work with Lynch Mob instead, on what became Wicked Sensation. Vinnie Paul says he left two days before recording began. The band turned to Terry Date, who had worked with Soundgarden, Metal Church and Overkill; Overkill's The Years of Decay had also shaped Darrell's guitar tone. Date would stay with Pantera through The Great Southern Trendkill in 1996.

The method was unorthodox. Vinnie Paul tracked drums first, Darrell added guitar, and Brown recorded bass against the guitars alone. That produced a tighter sound, and slight timing errors were fixed by cutting the tape by hand. Anselmo told The Skinny in 2010 that the album was recorded in 1989 with "no pro-tools, no tricks or whistles".

"Cemetery Gates" was the hard one for Anselmo. He broke a chair over a repeated note, telling Metal Hammer in 2010 "I broke a chair, I was so goddamn frustrated", and Date suggested port wine, the drink Chris Cornell reportedly used to warm his throat. Brown added strumming and alternate-picking parts and a backward-recorded piano crescendo built from eight grand pianos, according to Loudwire. He told Kik Axe that he and Darrell wrote the song's acoustic intro, which began on a Kramer acoustic bass he called a "big orange pumpkin bass".

In 2018 IK Multimedia modelled the gear Dimebag used on the album, working with his longtime guitar tech Grady Champion:

  • Amp: Randall RG 100ES, with a 1986 Roland JC120 used on "Cemetery Gates".
  • Cabinet: Randall 412JB.
  • Pedals: MXR six-band EQ, Furman PQ-3, MXR Flanger Doubler.
  • Wah and gate: Dunlop Cry Baby GCB95, Rocktron Hush IIB.

Anselmo has said the aim was to capture Darrell's monstrous guitar sound on tape, and acknowledged he is often asked about it being high-end and tinny. He has also said that "we, as a band, helped change the production of heavy metal records".

Personnel & Credits

RolePlayerNotes
Core band
VocalsPhil AnselmoLead vocals
GuitarsDiamond DarrellAlso additional bass on two tracks
BassRex BrownAcoustic guitar and piano on "Cemetery Gates"
DrumsVinnie PaulTracked first
Production and engineering
Producer, engineer, mixerTerry DateCo-producer credit for Pantera
Assistant engineersMatt Lane, Matt Gililland
MasteringHowie Weinberg

The album credits the guitarist as Diamond Darrell. He played additional bass on "Cowboys from Hell" and "Cemetery Gates", and Brown added rhythm guitar on the same two. The credits list no guest musicians.

The Songs

#TitleWriter(s)LengthSingle?Notes
1Cowboys from HellPantera4:06YesBuilt on a guitar part Darrell made on a four-track
2Primal Concrete SledgePantera2:13NoOne of the last two songs written
3Psycho HolidayPantera5:19YesCame from a two-day jam with "Heresy"
4HeresyPantera4:47NoLoudwire hears New Wave of British Heavy Metal in it
5Cemetery GatesPantera7:02PromoLongest Pantera song; piano and acoustic by Brown
6DominationPantera5:04NoFirst take kept, per Vinnie Paul
7ShatteredPantera3:22NoLoudwire hears New Wave of British Heavy Metal in it
8Clash with RealityPantera5:16NoOne of the last two songs written
9Medicine ManPantera5:15NoDemo version on the 2010 reissue
10Message in BloodPantera5:10NoDemo version on the 2010 reissue
11The SleepPantera5:47NoDemo version on the 2010 reissue
12The Art of ShreddingPantera4:18NoAmong the first songs written; D minor

Every song is credited to all four members of the band.

The title track opens with a noise Brown calls "just a Dime thing", a loop Darrell heard in his head. Brown connects the intro to blues sessions at Pantego, where the Abbotts' father engineered and the band would sneak in to sit under the board and listen. It first appeared on the 1989 demo, and Guitar World named it the best Pantera song.

"Psycho Holiday" still carries the last traces of the glam past, with high-pitched vocals, squealing guitars and big choruses. Its title was a dig at Anselmo. Brown told Metal Hammer in 2010 that Anselmo's short temper after the first demo prompted him to write the phrase on a pad because "he was psycho and he was going on a holiday".

"Cemetery Gates" is the album's ballad. Anselmo called it "just a riff that Dimebag wrote", and Loudwire reports he considered it a weak link, "a big compromise musically at the time", before singing it anyway. It ends on screamed high notes that Darrell answers on guitar.

"Domination" was written in the practice room, and Vinnie Paul says they kept the first take they recorded. It is played in E standard tuning, and it served as the live opener in 1990 and 1991. "The Art of Shredding" closes the record in D minor, and Guitar World ranked it the tenth best Pantera song.

B-sides, Outtakes & Lost Songs

"The Will to Survive" was recorded during the sessions but left off because it was more melodic than the rest. Anselmo called it "kind of a sore thumb sticking out". He has described it as a Judas Priest-ish power ballad, and parts of it were later used in "This Love" on Vulgar Display of Power. Brown says it was probably among the first written for the album and "just didn't make it". It finally surfaced in 2010.

Wikipedia lists the "Psycho Holiday" single as carrying live versions of "Cowboys from Hell" and "Heresy" as extra tracks.

Album Artwork & Packaging

Sepia front cover of Cowboys from Hell: four band members in modern clothes pasted into an old photograph of an ornate saloon with antlers on the wall
The cover of Cowboys from Hell, a 1910 saloon photograph with Pantera added.

The sleeve is a sepia saloon interior with patterned wallpaper and ceiling, antlers on the back wall and a white-shirted barman behind the counter. A roulette-style table fills the bottom left, and the band's name sits at top left in chunky, distressed white capitals with the album title in black on a white strip below.

The room is a 1910 photograph of the Cosmopolitan Saloon in Telluride, Colorado, with the band pasted in. Darrell is at centre, sprawled on the floor with his guitar, Vinnie Paul stands to his right counting money, Brown leans on the counter, and Anselmo is mid-air above the bar. Anselmo says he jumped from a bar stool, and it took about ten takes to get the shot.

Release & Reception

The album came out on cassette, CD and vinyl, plus a limited long-box edition. It sold slowly and steadily through the 1990s and first charted on Billboard in 1992, reaching No. 27 on the Top Heatseekers. It entered the Swedish chart at No. 46 in March 1995. Pantera's first platinum award, for this album, came in July 1997, and the RIAA made it 2x Platinum on 26 May 2023. It is also Gold in the UK, Argentina, Australia and Japan.

The critical case has been built retrospectively:

  • AllMusic gives four stars.
  • IGN says Darrell "rips the strings of his axe like a rabid weasel", and ranks it the 19th most influential heavy metal album.
  • The Rolling Stone Album Guide gives 3.5 stars and Martin Popoff's Collector's Guide to Heavy Metal gives 9/10.
  • Guitar World put it 11th on its 2006 list of the 100 greatest guitar albums, and Metal-Rules.com ranked it 85th among heavy metal albums.

Ultimate Classic Rock called it "a bona fide musical revelation", warmly embraced by specialised metal publications and extreme-tasted fans alike.

Singles & Music Videos

SingleYearNotes
Cowboys from Hell1990First single; video directed by Paul Rachman
Psycho Holiday1990Second and final single; video directed by Paul Rachman
Cemetery Gates1990Promotional single; shorter video edit without the acoustic opening

The videos for "Cowboys from Hell" and "Psycho Holiday" were both shot at The Basement, a Dallas club the band frequented, and the "Cowboys from Hell" clip shows them playing live to a crowd. They were collected on the VHS Cowboys from Hell: The Videos (2 April 1991), a tour documentary with six videos, and the RIAA lists a Gold video longform award for Cowboys From Hell dated 9 July 1996.

Touring & Live

Pantera toured for nearly two years. Loudwire counts over 300 dates. Their first national tour, in summer 1990, supported Exodus and Suicidal Tendencies. Further support slots, per Wikipedia, included Skid Row, Sepultura, Fates Warning, Prong, Mind Over Four, Morbid Angel, White Zombie and Sanctuary, and they co-headlined a North American run with Wrathchild America.

In 1991 Rob Halford joined them onstage, which led to Pantera and Annihilator opening Judas Priest's first European show. In September 1991 they played Monsters of Rock in Moscow with AC/DC, Mötley Crüe, Metallica and The Black Crowes, before a crowd of over 500,000. Seven live tracks from a 15 September 1990 Foundations Forum show in California, recorded for radio, were released in 2010.

In TV, Film & Media

"Cowboys from Hell" plays over the gym montage in episode nine of That '90s Show, "Dirty Double Booker", which Loudwire covered in January 2023. A 5:47 edit of "Cemetery Gates" appeared on the soundtrack of the 1995 film Tales from the Crypt Presents Demon Knight.

Controversy, Censorship & Lawsuits

Members of New Orleans band Exhorder have alleged that Pantera copied their late-1980s demos when they switched from glam to groove metal. Cowboys from Hell appeared just before Exhorder's debut. AllMusic noted "striking similarities", while KNAC contributor Brian Davis called the clone claim ludicrous. Exhorder singer Kyle Thomas has since said he does not care about the criticism and mourns Dimebag.

Reissues, Remasters & Anniversaries

Rhino issued the 20th anniversary edition on 14 September 2010, remastered from the original analogue tapes. It debuted at No. 117 on the Billboard 200 on sales of about 4,200 copies.

EditionContents
Expanded (2 CD)Remaster, plus the Foundations Forum tracks and the Alive and Hostile EP recorded in Moscow in 1991
Deluxe (3 CD)Adds a disc of "The Will to Survive" and demos of 10 of the 12 songs
Ultimate (November 2010)60-page booklet, essays from band, Terry Date and Mark Ross, replica memorabilia

The demo disc was also pressed as Cowboys from Hell: The Demos, a 3,000-copy limited vinyl run sold through Metal Club stores around Black Friday 2010. The Alive and Hostile EP tracks had not been released in the US before.

Legacy & Influence

The follow-up, Vulgar Display of Power, came out on 25 February 1992, and Far Beyond Driven debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 in 1994. The band broke up in November 2003. Dimebag Darrell was shot dead on stage in Columbus, Ohio, on 8 December 2004, and Vinnie Paul died in June 2018. Pantera played their first show in more than 21 years at Mexico's Hell & Heaven Metal Fest on 2 December 2022, and now tour with Anselmo, Brown, Zakk Wylde and Charlie Benante.

Ozzy Osbourne listed the album among his ten favourite metal albums in 2017. A live "Cemetery Gates" was nominated for Best Metal Performance at the 1998 Grammys. V13's 2020 retro review said it "continues to define what an 'authentic' metal record 'should' be". For where the sound went next, see Vulgar Display of Power and Far Beyond Driven.

Things You Might Not Know

FactDetail
A borrowed title"Cemetery Gates" is named after The Smiths' "Cemetry Gates", and Anselmo has said he is a big Smiths fan.
Solo pollGuitar World readers voted the "Cemetery Gates" solo the 35th greatest of all time, Dimebag's second-highest placing after "Floods".
Video cameosThe 1991 VHS Cowboys from Hell: The Videos features guest appearances from members of Alice in Chains, Judas Priest and Slayer.
The Puke Party shirtThe 2010 Ultimate Edition included a replica of the New Year's Puke Party T-shirt designed by Dimebag Darrell.

Listen to the Riffology Podcast

The Riffology podcast is available on all major platforms, so find your preferred app and join us for more stories behind the records that shaped heavy music.